Old-Fashioned Sugar Cookies - Mrs. Allen's Recipe

Mrs. Allen's cookies. No, this is not a new grocery store brand, but another installment in the Aunt Lou's Archives series. By the way, Mrs. Allen was a real person. So, who was she? How did her old-fashioned sugar cookie recipe end up in Aunt Lou's hands? Whether she was a neighbor, the grocer's wife, or a church friend, we will never know.

Old-fashioned sugar cookies

Mrs. Allen's cookies. No, this is not a new grocery store brand, but another installment in the Aunt Lou's Archives series. By the way, Mrs. Allen was a real person. So, who was she? How did her old-fashioned sugar cookie recipe end up in Aunt Lou's hands? Whether she was a neighbor, the grocer's wife, or a church friend, we will never know.

I am however thankful that at some point in time, Mrs. Allen cookie recipe made its way to Aunt Lou's kitchen and consequently to mine. It goes without saying that this old-fashioned recipe contained no instructions. My husband checked with his mother who has made these many times. I must admit, the dough/batter is rather unusual as far as cookies go. It looks a bit more like biscuit dough.  My husband's grandmother Kathryn McEvoy fondly referred to as Grandma Mac "improved" upon the original recipe by adding lemon juice and vanilla, just so you know. Thank you Grandma Mac!!!

Dunking Tips

Better dunkability (?). My husband remembers his grandmother (Aunt Lou's niece) making these raisin cookies for him and his brothers. They would anxiously wait at her kitchen table with a glass of whole milk at the ready. There was a "method" to eating these cookies. First you either had to break off a piece or take a small bite. Yes, this was the way. "Why?" I asked, slightly puzzled. According to him, breaking off a chunk before dunking made the cookie more  absorbent and "dunk-able". Yes, dunkable is a word.

The Texture

A blissful marriage between a cake and a cookie. They have that soft interior that gives them its "cakey" quality. The sour cream in the recipe certainly contributes to this marvelous texture. Did I say sour cream? Wait a minute! Sour cream wasn't commercially available until about 50 years ago.  This recipe dates from the Depression Era. So, where would Aunt Lou have found sour cream in the early 30's? Well, she made it of course. To make sour cream, she would've taken 1 pint of cream a little bit of lemon juice and left it on the counter for about 3 days.  (There is an old pint of cream in the photo above. ) Yeah, 3 days! A quick sniff would have told her that it was ready. Now, that is some serious planning!!

Why One Raisin?

Mrs. Allen's cookies have one raisin in the middle. This is the way they were made. Raisins were most likely expensive during the Depression. My husband's grandmother never added more raisins, a quiet reminder of more difficult times. My husband and his brothers often asked "Grandma, can we have more raisins?" "No" she would smile and say. "Only one". Consequently, today, my mother in law makes them the same way: with one raisin. We will carry on the minimalist tradition. Less is more. Mrs. Allen would be proud.

Want to try more old-fashioned recipes from the family vault? Below are some of my recommendations 

Hermit Cookie - These old-fashioned spice cookies are meant to imitate the look of a "hermit's bag." 

Chocolate Drop Cookies - These chocolate cookies are chewy and crunchy. Serve them with a glass of milk. 

Aunt Lou's $200 Cake - The ultimate cake to bring to your next party. It's not too sweet and the strawberry frosting adds the perfect lightness to it. 

Looking for more recipes?  
Sign up for my free recipe newsletter to get new recipes in your inbox each week!  You can also find me sharing more inspiration in Pinterest and Facebook

📖 Recipe

Old Fashioned Sugar Cookies Recipe - Mrs. Allen's Cookies

Analida Braeger

An old fashioned sugar cookie recipe handed down through generations. This makes a very soft cake like cookie that is perfect for dunking.  These have a nice rich flavor and are made with sour cream.

5 from 1 vote

Print Recipe Rate this Recipe

Prep Time 20 minutes mins

Cook Time 10 minutes mins

Total Time 30 minutes mins

Course Dessert

Cuisine American

Servings 12 servings

Calories 465 kcal

Ingredients

  

1x2x3x

• 2 ½ cups sugar
• 1 cup butter
• 1 cup sour cream
• 1 teaspoon vanilla
• 1 teaspoon lemon fresh squeezed juice
• 3 cups flour
• 2 teaspoon baking powder
• 1 teaspoon baking soda
• 1 pinch salt
• 1 pinch nutmeg
• 3 eggs separated

Cook Mode(Keep screen awake)

Instructions

 

• Cream the butter and sugar together until fluffy. Add sour cream, lemon juice, egg yolks, and vanilla. Mix well.
• In a separate bowl, sift the flour with the baking powder, salt, nutmeg, and baking soda.
• Slowly add the flour mixture to the batter. Mix well until it begins to form a ball.
• Beat egg whites until they begin to form stiff peaks. Slowly fold into the batter.
• Working in batches, take 1 cup of dough and dust with enough flour to be able to roll the dough on a floured surface to ⅓" thick.
• Using a biscuit cutter, cut into 2" rounds.
• Place on parchment paper about 2" apart. Place one raisin in the middle of each cookie.
• Bake for about 8-10 minutes at 350 F

Nutrition

Calories: 465kcalCarbohydrates: 66gProtein: 5gFat: 20gSaturated Fat: 12gCholesterol: 91mgSodium: 275mgPotassium: 164mgSugar: 42gVitamin A: 650IUVitamin C: 0.4mgCalcium: 73mgIron: 1.8mg

Keyword baking, good dunking cookie, scratch recipe, vanilla cookie

Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!